Faye’s Philosophy

Faye Berryman AM, Fitzroy Community School co-founder, talks about the school's philosophy.

Hierarchy of Values


Ethos - by Faye Berryman

FCS is not an ordinary school. It’s important to reflect on what students receive here that they would not find elsewhere. What actually makes FCS different? How can we say, honestly, that we are a genuine alternative to what is normally offered?

The FCS ethos rests on two convictions:

First, we take responsibility for our input into the social, emotional, and ethical dimensions of child development.

Second, we believe that the deliberately constructed lifestyle of FCS enables us to support that development on this broad front.


The Lifestyle of FCS

The lifestyle of FCS is a very deliberate choice. I want to draw attention to why this particular lifestyle matters so much in the development of the whole child. We spend less time than most schools in the formal classroom. Why? Why do we give camps — our kind of camps — such emphasis? Why is free time an essential part of our day — arguably the most important part? Why do we take children on so many excursions? And why do we offer them significant unstructured time in nature?

Children spend many hours each day, over thirteen years, at school. These years, particularly the primary ones, are the most significant in a child’s social, ethical, and emotional development. Positive development in these areas most strongly determines success as a whole person. For this reason, FCS believes that school hours are far too important to devote to academic proficiency alone. Academic excellence is wonderful — but it is achievable. In a hierarchy of values, FCS places goodness and viability first.


Link to The Wider World

At FCS, we have established a way of life that more closely reflects life in the wider world. It allows each child to be seen and known by the community. It gives young people opportunities to come to know themselves as they relate with a variety of others, young and old — to learn which behaviours result in positive exchanges and which lead to unhappiness.

If you wonder why we give children free time, ask what children are like when they are not being told what to do. What are their strengths and weaknesses? If they can discover these, they can evolve, and we can encourage growth. This is the true meaning of education — a far cry from mere schooling.

All children, along the pathway from childhood to adult life, contend with a variety of influences — some conflicting. Consequently, children experiment with many ways of being. They depend on the significant adults in their lives to give them authentic feedback on the acceptability — or otherwise — of the behaviours they display.

Along the pathway from childhood to adult life, all children contend with a variety of influences—some of them conflicting—at any given time. Consequently, children experiment with many ways of being. Children depend on the significant adults in their lives to give them authentic feedback on the acceptability, or otherwise, of the behaviours and attitudes they display.


 The original FCS bus – built by Phillip 

Origins of the School


The Questioning

What follows is a presentation of the ‘conversation’ that Faye and Philip had in starting the school. This is in 1976 and Faye and Philip then had three school age children and were reflecting upon what/where/how they should be schooled.

Our Initial Questions

We asked each other, “Where shall we send our children for schooling?”

We decided to approach the question rationally and asked first, “What is the purpose of schooling?”

"To enable the child to participate in the world confidently, competently, and happily,” we supposed. “By what method does schooling achieve this goal?” we wondered.

The most important skills

We mumbled the usual things like the teaching of reading, writing, arithmetic, etc., and then summarised this as the development of various skills.

We then asked ourselves, “What are the most important skills for a child to grow in?”

Reflecting on our own life experiences and on the causes of unhappiness that we could see in the world around us, it did not take us long to agree that the most pressing aspect of development for any young human was interpersonal communication skills. This was the key to long-term success in both personal life and career satisfaction.

This then was our first strong conviction on the subject of schooling.


Challenges with Traditional Schools

Assessing Available Schools

With a sense of relief that we finally knew what we were looking for, we settled back into our armchairs and asked the innocuous question “Which schools best serve this need of children?”

But our comfort was short-lived as it soon became painfully obvious, mentally scanning the selection of schools available, that the school industry largely neglected children in this most important of all areas!

Problems with Traditional Schooling

If you compare a group of school beginners with a group of school leavers you have a stark demonstration of a hidden curriculum that actually robs children of their expressive and communicative powers – and with it the all-important self-confidence.

Help! It was becoming obvious why parents generally avoid examining school life too closely. You have to give your children over to a school, but what is a parent meant to do when they discover that the school they’ve just looked at is not just failing to achieve the aspirations they hold for their child, but appears unaware that the nature of the schooling experience even matters.

We expressed our concerns to anyone who would listen and soon found ourselves joining a group of parents to form an alternative school. High hopes. A great pool of parental energy. Several eager meetings.

Internal Strife in Alternative Schools

But dark clouds again... We found that, meeting by meeting, the parent group was becoming more harshly divided. These parents were dedicated, concerned, and like us, opinionated. It is after all the right and duty of parents to raise their children according to their values and beliefs. But there were so many areas of conflict. There were as many theories as to how the school should be run as there were parents. Even spouses were divided!

The movement collapsed before our eyes. Unbeknown to us at the time, the same distressing experience was befalling earnest parents all over the country.

In 1975 in Melbourne, we joined an established alternative school. We contributed our goodwill, our time, our fees and our children. But alas, the same problem of in-fighting was eating up this school too.

Realising the Committee System's Flaws

We investigated and soon came to discover that “community” schools everywhere were collapsing from within. The committee system (which might be essential in some large organisations), when applied to small-scale, self-governing schools was shredding any hope of effectiveness – or even survival. All around Melbourne, these new alternative schools were falling like flies.


A New Type Of School

November 1976 - A Bold New Idea

We were on the verge of giving up all hope of finding a school that truly served the child, when a bold thought entered our heads. We could START OUR OWN SCHOOL.

Faye had been a secondary teacher and a social worker. Philip had been a university philosophy lecturer and had written on education. We knew what we wanted in a school. In a nutshell, our vision for school was a place that in which the children enjoyed a happy lifestyle, and which encouraged interpersonal communication skills and grew self-confidence.

Establishing the School

We felt that we could bring this about through creating, from day one, the culture and structures we felt best supported children to grow. To this end, we reflected that a small school gave us the greatest ability to form the culture we wanted, and if we added small class sizes, the relationships would be strong and real – not institutional or distant.

We also came to the view that the children would benefit if the school was welcoming to school families. Parental presence at school would indicate to the children that their parents affirmed the school as a good place to be. Also, the children’s engagement with a wider circle of adults would mean exposure to a wider circle of ideas and approaches, which would bring gains to their effective immersion in the world outside of school.

Our thoughts, having been clarified on the type of school we intended to open, now turned to the bureaucratic hurdles we now faced. The question became:

How could we break through the obstructive and exhausting tangle of red tape associated with the founding of a new school?

We could not. But we judged that our obligation to children was greater than our obligation to bureaucracy.

So without even rising from the kitchen table, we declared the school open. There were 12 children in attendance the following morning. Four years later our little school was officially registered.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls

But wait. How shall we avoid the internal strife that has befallen the other community schools? Here, we had to seriously depart from the common practices of the day and say, “Not run by committee.”

We made the clear decision that FCS would be our school – meaning that we’d run it, and as such be responsible for its culture and practices. We’d offer our educational vision to the world, and happily engage with families who were seeking the type of childhood experiences we were offering.

The committee system on paper appears to give parents power, but all they tend to end up with is a tense, low-morale, den of intrigue. True power lies in being able to choose or reject a school. Choice is meaningless without diversity.

Our approach offered then, and continues to offer parents a school which can actually get on with the job, and lives its educational vision. It is experienced as a happy place to work, which has paid dividends for the staff and the children they educate for many decades.

Growth and Success

Within 2 weeks we had a full house of 20 children. 2 years later, we purchased the adjoining house and accepted 40 pupils. In 1994, we sold our home to the school, thereby opening up all rooms, and bought the house next door. We’ve educated 55-65 students at our Brunswick Street site for decades, and now offer our very special primary school experience to a similar number at our Normanby Avenue campus. We are lucky to have never advertised.

Our broad aspiration is that many more educators with vision will open small primary schools, allowing parents everywhere the opportunity to choose a school that aligns with their view of schooling.

Boy doing jigsaw

“If you wonder why we give them freetime, ask what children are like when they are not being told what to do.”

— Faye Berryman (founder)

Ball Game

“Despite spending less time in class than the average school, we consistently produce nation-leading academic outcomes… while having a lot of fun and many adventures along the way.”

The Hidden Curriculum


The Learning Iceberg

In our civilisation, compulsory schooling — for better or for worse — dominates the timetable of childhood. From around the age of five through to young adulthood, most of each day and most of the year is taken up with schooling.

Officially, school exists to teach children the skills they need to be employable — reading, writing, arithmetic. This is the curriculum.

But the official curriculum is only the tip of the learning iceberg. Because of the moulding power of this second home, the child will inevitably acquire other learning too — attitudes, behaviours, and a particular view of the world. Ivan Illich, in his classic text Deschooling Society, called this the Hidden Curriculum. Despite its significant influence, it is rarely discussed.


Adult & Child Connection

Adult relations within the school must be positive and affirming. This is why the educator hires staff who genuinely value their subjects — whether music, maths, or literature. Children will notice whether we treasure a subject far more than the content of the textbooks we use.


Love of Learning

Despite spending significantly less time on literacy and numeracy than comparable schools, FCS consistently achieves great academic results. In addition to these outcomes, our success includes inculcating a love of learning and habits of study that carry through to higher levels and later life. These outcomes occur because the time we spend in class is fruitful. We do not find it necessary to disguise, decorate, or apologise for the subjects we teach. If we present Maths and English as treasures, they receive them as treasures. That is why the educator responsible will always seek to employ teachers who treasure their subject.


Treasures Passed On

The other notable effect of engaging in the spirit of learning is that we do not find it necessary to disguise, decorate, or in any way apologise for the subjects we teach. Our English and Maths for example are presented directly as skills enjoyable in their own right.

Nor do we expect young children to make judgments about the true worth of whatever material we may try to teach them. This is our job as their elders - those who have gone before. They have not lived long enough to make such judgments.

Children have a biological instinct to value what we value. If we present Maths and English as treasures, they receive them as treasures, and will happily acquire the skills without sugar coating.

Contrary to the prevailing practice of trying to teach incidentally by a thematic approach (let’s do kangaroos today), we focus directly on the respective skills - such as reading, handwriting, creative writing, spelling, speech, and grammar.

We their teachers must believe in the value of what we teach – they will then receive it with open arms. That is why the Educator responsible (the principal of FCS) will always seek to employ teachers who treasure their subject. This quality we have found is worth far more than the mere holding a state-recognised document of teacher qualification.


Free Time


Free time is a regular feature on the timetable. It is the time when our children decide for themselves what they want to do and how they will do it. Choosing from a list of electives is qualitatively different to choosing without restriction. Doing ‘nothing’ is as valuable as anything else, if it is the child’s choice.

FCS sees significant benefit in the child discovering what they like — what genuinely engages them. This underpins not just their motivations, but whether they find meaning in their activities and pursuits. A child who does not know what they like is a disempowered person.

In children’s busy worlds — full of ballet, basketball, swimming, yoga, violin, and the ever-present screen — free time provides a small gap to dream and discover.

It also provides an opportunity for children to learn how to play with each other: to discover which actions and demeanour draw others in, and which push them away. Kindness and care flourish during free time. So does negotiation, compromise, and — in mixed-age groups — the easy generosity of older children toward younger ones.

Free time is not simply pleasant. It is foundational to self-discovery and the emergence of a happy, inclusive school culture.


The difference is subtle. But the difference becomes obvious through the child's development over time.

Camp


What Happens On Camp

Over the course of camp, there will be one or two organised activities per day — a walk, a session of wood collecting, an exploration of some aspect of the bush. These will total 45–90 minutes of the day, leaving the majority of the time free for the children to explore, dream, and connect.

What do the children do? They learn — in the true sense. They discover themselves: what they like, what they want to do. This is culturally different to the busy, organised lives of many modern children. The children experience genuine free time in nature which is fairly unique.

The object is that children learn and discover that they can — successfully and happily — organise themselves. That they can sort out turns on the swing and the trampoline, take care of their own eating, cope with being muddy or wet, manage a night away from home. Our ongoing experience is that conquering these small challenges builds the ability to conquer increasingly larger ones.

The children return from camp proud of what they have achieved. They walk taller — if dirtier — and are empowered by the encounter with their own inner strength.


Boy in a creek
knitting on camp by the fire Girl with swing
Girl with swing

Eccentricity


Eccentricity

It is never our aim at FCS to make all children the same, to transform each individual into some idealised norm. Many eccentrics have made great contributions and they all started out as children!

Children are different in many ways: some are more cerebral while others are highly tactile. Some children are artistic, some empathic, while others are natural listeners. Certain children are highly active while others are quiet and shy, to name just a small subset of the many traits demonstrated by a group of children. At FCS we see all types as having a place and role to play in society – we need them all.

This approach of FCS, unique in the 1970s with its more rigid educational settings, is now relatively mainstream. The modern approach appears at times to forget that connected children are happy children. This can, in certain situations, lead to a failure by parents and teachers to give appropriate feedback to our eccentrics – that is, it can manifest in a failure to address traits and mannerisms that we adults know will push others away. At FCS, we don’t wish eccentricity to be a pathway to a sad, lonely sad future.

We love our eccentrics, but don’t see eccentricity as a reason to not engage in raising children who others will want to be around.


The Role of Parents

There are some attitudes and behaviours which are necessary for any individual to thrive in any human society. The essential social or co-existence skills come very naturally to some children, and have to be laboriously learnt by others. Parents are the primary teachers in this area – and their good work can be reinforced by teachers at school.

There are a small number of parents who think that their child is somehow exempt or can be continually excused from the universal duty to respect one’s fellow humans. In this situation there is clear difference of opinion between the school and the family. It is our ongoing experience that in this situation the family’s position will prevail as the child looks to their parents for guidance first and foremost.

Our concern here stems from our understanding that parents cannot keep their children forever. Children, irrespective of how they are viewed by their parents, will at some point need to learn to respect others or they will suffer a diminished quality of life.

This situation very occasionally leads to the saddest interactions we have with parents, where they share that while they love their children, they don’t actually like them. These parents disclose that they don’t enjoy their children’s company due to the way that their child treats those around them.

Our mission is to work with parents to raise children who others want to be around. To this end, we are willing to directly share our observations regarding the way that children push others away.


Navigating Social Skills

No-one is saying that social learning is equally easy for every child. However, there are minimum behavioural requirements which apply to everybody within any society. Some children have to learn the social contract more consciously and deliberately than others – with clear, consistent and compatible parent and teacher input. Children who are genuinely incapable of learning the social mores are rare, and face a future in which they will have difficulties in their interactions with others in the community. We try to assist all children as best we can in social learning.

If we at FCS see a child falling behind in age-appropriate social skills, and if our efforts to impart them are unsuccessful, our next step is to organise a chat with parents to see if we can achieve a co-ordinated approach. In the extreme case, if the parents cannot see eye-to-eye with us on the need for learning respect for one’s fellows, we know we are not benefiting the child, and we may ask them to look for a solution elsewhere.


hanging paper cranes
FCS The Book

FCS - The Book is Faye and Philip's story of their journey in founding and running their school for nearly three decades, before handing their treasured gift to their son Tim. The book recounts the founding of the school, difficulties encountered, discoveries made and their vision for a better quality of childhood for all Australian children. A must read for those interested in education, schooling and childhood.

FCS The Book

Faye and Phillip’s education journey has been translated into Chinese and inspired many parents and educators in this vast land.

If you’re a parent curious about our school, click the link below

Prospective Parents